Owner Resources

Peer Networks for Roofing Business Owners: How to Find and Use One

A gloved roofer steadying a cordless driver against timber battens on a roof under framing

A peer network for roofing business owners is a small group of owners who meet on a schedule, compare how they run their companies and hold each other to decisions. You can find one through a roofing trade association, an SBA resource partner, a local business group, or by building your own with owners outside your market.

What a peer network is, and what it is not

The roofing owner’s problem is that nobody above you asks hard questions. Foremen report to you, customers want a price, and your spouse or partner has heard enough about the business. A peer network fills that gap. It is a group of owners who understand the pressures you face because they face them too, and who will look at a decision you are about to make and tell you what they see.

It is not a networking breakfast or a referral club. Members may send each other work, but that is a side effect. The value is in honest comparison: how another owner priced a commercial bid, handled a crew leader who quit, changed a safety program after a fall, or prepared for a sale. Done well, it is the outside board of directors a small company does not otherwise have.

Roofing trade associations and their peer programs

A trade association is the clearest route to owners who know the trade. The National Roofing Contractors Association says that through its Peer Networking Program, contractor members seeking advice, knowledge, guidance and industry best practices can connect one on one with members who have volunteered their time to share their knowledge, insight and expertise. Its page adds that matching with like-minded industry peers will let members connect, learn and discuss changes in their business.

National associations also work alongside regional, state and local groups. The National Roofing Contractors Association lists international, national, regional, state and local organizations represented through its affiliate network and says that together they create collaborative opportunities to advance the roofing industry. A state or regional roofing association can be the place where you meet owners close enough to understand your market and far enough away not to bid against you. Ask the association what programs it runs for owners, and whether it can introduce you to members at a similar stage.

SBA resource partners: mentors and advisers

The Small Business Administration lists resource partners that offer counseling, training and mentoring to small business owners. These are not roofing-specific, but they can give you an experienced outside voice on finance, hiring and planning.

The Small Business Administration says SCORE mentors offer area-specific advice at no cost on topics including financing, human resources and business planning, and that SCORE provides a wide range of services including training, webinars and online workshops. It says Small Business Development Centers provide counseling and training to small businesses. It describes Women’s Business Centers as offering free to low-cost counseling and training, and says its Veterans Business Outreach Centers offer workshops, training, counseling and mentorship opportunities. A mentor relationship is different from a peer group, since it runs in one direction, but it can be a useful complement, and these partners may know of local owner groups worth joining.

Building your own group

If nothing nearby fits, you can build a group. Reach out to roofing owners you respect in other markets, perhaps people you met at a trade show, a product training session or an association meeting. Owners in adjacent trades, such as siding or gutters, can also understand your problems without competing for your jobs.

Keep the group small enough that everyone speaks at every meeting. Agree on a schedule, a format and a confidentiality rule at the start, and write them down. Rotate who leads. The groups that last are the ones where every member brings something real and leaves with a commitment.

How a roofing owner finds and uses a peer network A stacked diagram of how a roofing owner finds and uses a peer network. Finding the group can start with a trade association program, a Small Business Administration resource partner or a circle the owner builds. Choosing members means owners at a similar stage who do not bid against you. Members bring real decisions about numbers, contracts, crews, safety and succession. Each member leaves with a commitment that is checked at the next meeting. The closing band says to keep pricing talk with competitors out of the room. No figures or dollar amounts are shown. Finding and using a roofing peer network Find the group A trade association program, an SBA partner or your own Choose the members Owners at a similar stage who do not bid against you Bring real decisions Numbers, contracts, crews, safety and succession Report back A commitment from each meeting, checked at the next Keep pricing talk with competitors out of the room.
A peer network works when members at a similar stage bring real decisions and hold each other to what they commit.

How to choose the right group

The right group is made of owners at a similar stage, facing similar decisions, who do not compete with you. An owner running a single crew and an owner running several divisions can both learn from each other, but their daily problems differ, and a big gap in size can turn the group into a lecture. Look for members who are a step or two ahead of you on the path you want to take.

Look at how the group runs. Ask how members are selected, what the meeting schedule is, whether there is a facilitator, what it costs, what is expected of members and what happens when someone stops showing up. A group with no structure fades. A group with too much structure can feel like homework. Visit a meeting before you commit if the group allows it.

Real-World Scenario: A roofing owner who has grown from a single crew to several is about to sign a large commercial contract and is unsure about its insurance requirements. At a peer group meeting, another owner from a different state describes how a similar contract caught him with an endorsement he did not have. The first owner sends the contract to his agent before signing and has the coverage questions answered first. The group did not give legal advice; it pointed to the question worth asking.

How to get value from the meetings

Bring real decisions and real numbers. If you are deciding whether to add a crew, bring the backlog, the payroll you expect and the equipment you would need. If you are struggling with turnover, bring what you pay and what you offer. Vague questions get vague answers.

Leave each meeting with a commitment and report on it at the next one. That accountability is hard to find anywhere else. Over time, the group learns your company well enough to notice when you are avoiding a problem.

Topics worth bringing include crew hiring and retention, which the post on hiring and retaining roofing crews covers, and safety programs, where the posts on OSHA fall protection and how to reduce claims give you a starting point. Growth decisions fit too; the post on how to grow a roofing business covers the contract and insurance side. Succession and sale questions are among the hardest to discuss with anyone inside the company, which makes them ideal for a peer group. The posts on whether to partner with a platform or stay independent and on alternatives to a national consolidator give you a framework to bring.

Insurance is a good topic to compare

Insurance can come up among owners only as a complaint about price. A peer group is a place to compare the habits behind the price: how members check subcontractor certificates, how they report a claim, what their safety meetings look like and how they prepare for a renewal. Those habits are things an owner can change, and they show up in how an underwriter sees the account.

A peer group cannot tell you what your premium should be. Your premium depends on your payroll, your work, your record and your state. The post on what drives roofing workers’ comp costs explains why another owner’s number may tell you little about yours. Take what you learn to your agent. The coverage checklist and the post on what underwriters ask for can help you turn a peer’s story into a specific question for your own program.

What to keep out of the room

Do not discuss prices, bids or which customers each member will pursue with owners who compete with you. Agreements among competitors on those subjects can raise serious legal problems, and a casual conversation can look different later. That is one more reason to build a group from owners outside your market. If a group includes local competitors, ask an attorney what topics are off limits.

Keep customer information confidential, and respect the group’s confidentiality rule about members’ own numbers. A group where members fear their numbers will leak is a group where nobody brings real numbers.

Questions to ask before you join a group

  • Are the members at a similar stage, and do any of them compete with me?
  • What is the meeting schedule, and who leads the meetings?
  • What does membership cost, and what is expected of each member?
  • What is the confidentiality rule, and is it written down?
  • How are new members chosen, and how are members removed?
  • Can I attend a meeting before I commit?
  • What topics does the group avoid, and has anyone asked an attorney?

For the insurance questions a peer group will raise, start with the roofing insurance hub or the quote page. Sources: the National Roofing Contractors Association’s Peer Networking Program page, the National Roofing Contractors Association’s affiliates page, the Small Business Administration’s resource partners page, its SCORE mentoring page and its Small Business Development Centers page. This post is general education, not legal, tax or investment advice.

The bottom line

A peer network gives a roofing owner what the job rarely provides: other owners who understand the work, will look at your numbers and will ask whether you did what you said you would. You can find one through a roofing trade association’s peer program, an SBA resource partner such as SCORE or a Small Business Development Center, a local business group, or a circle you build yourself with owners outside your market. Pick a group with members at a similar stage, bring real decisions to every meeting, and keep pricing talk with direct competitors out of the room. This post is general education, not legal, tax or investment advice.

Frequently asked questions

What is a peer network for roofing business owners?

A peer network is a group of business owners who meet regularly to discuss how they run their companies, share what has worked and hold each other to decisions. For a roofing owner, the best fit is a group of owners at a similar stage who do not bid against you. It is not a sales club or a referral swap, though members may refer work to each other.

Where can a roofing owner find a peer group?

Start with a roofing trade association. The National Roofing Contractors Association says contractor members can connect one on one with members who have volunteered to share their knowledge through its Peer Networking Program. The Small Business Administration’s resource partners, including SCORE and Small Business Development Centers, offer mentoring and advising. You can also build a group with owners from other markets.

Does SCORE offer free mentoring for contractors?

Yes. The Small Business Administration says SCORE mentors offer area-specific advice at no cost on topics such as financing, human resources and business planning, and that SCORE also provides training, webinars and online workshops. A SCORE mentor is not a roofing peer group, but an experienced mentor can be a useful outside voice on finance, hiring and planning questions.

Should I join a peer group with roofers from my own market?

It is safer and more useful to join one with owners outside your market. Owners who do not compete with you can share numbers, problems and contract experiences more openly. Agreeing with competitors on prices, bids or which customers each will pursue can raise serious legal problems, so if a group includes local competitors, ask an attorney what topics are off limits before you speak.

What should roofing owners discuss in a peer group?

Bring real decisions and real numbers. Useful topics include hiring and keeping crews, safety programs, claims and how they were handled, contract terms from general contractors, insurance renewals, growth plans and succession. Each member should leave each meeting with a commitment and report back on it at the next one. A group that only trades stories turns into a social hour.

Can a peer group help with insurance costs?

It can help indirectly. Comparing how other owners run safety programs, report claims, check subcontractor certificates and prepare for renewal can show you habits worth copying. A peer group cannot tell you what your premium should be, because your premium depends on your own payroll, work and record. Take what you learn to your agent and ask what it could change at your next renewal.

About the author

Nate Jones, CPCU

Nate Jones, CPCU, is the founder of Wexford Insurance and Roofing Guard Insurance, a specialty insurance agency placing roofing contractor coverage in 48 states across a 16-carrier specialty panel. He works with roofing owners who belong to peer groups and owners who run their companies alone, and he sees the difference at renewal: owners who compare safety programs, claims habits and contract terms with other owners arrive with better questions. This page explains how to find and use a group and leaves membership choices to the owner. Connect via the Roofing Guard Insurance quote form or call 317-942-0549.

Insure your roofing operation with a CPCU-led agency

Tell us how you work — residential steep-slope, commercial and industrial low-slope and torch-down, or specialty metal and tile — and we will market it to carriers that write the roofing class.