Owner Resources

Alternatives to Selling to a National Roofing Consolidator

A roofer in gloves and a tool belt fastening timber battens over roof sheathing, seen from below the eave

You do not have to sell to a national consolidator to step back, cash out or retire. A roofing owner can sell to a key employee, pass the company to family, sell to a local roofer, sell gradually or lease the business, set up employee ownership, sell a minority share, hire a manager, or close in an orderly way.

How consolidation affects independent roofers

Investor-backed groups buying roofing companies change the market for everyone in it, including owners who never take a call from them. A local independent can find itself bidding against a rival with central purchasing, a formal safety department and a larger insurance program behind its certificates. The same groups compete for foremen and crews. The post on who buys roofing businesses describes who these buyers are.

Consolidation also changes the exit conversation. When one kind of buyer is loud and active, it is easy to treat its offer as the only real one. It is not. The Small Business Administration describes several ways to transfer ownership, including selling in full, a gradual sale and a lease, and any of them can be arranged with someone other than a national group. If you are weighing a platform against staying put, the post on whether to partner with a platform or stay independent covers that choice. This post maps the other doors.

Selling to a key employee or your management team

The person who already runs your crews or your estimating may be the buyer who understands the company best. A foreman, an operations manager or a small group of managers can buy the business and keep it running the way customers expect. The challenge is money: an employee buyer may not have the full price at closing.

That is where a payment plan comes in. Under the Internal Revenue Service’s definition, a sale becomes an installment sale when you receive at least one payment after the tax year in which the sale happens. A seller who finances part of the price is also taking a risk that the buyer cannot pay, so the terms, the security and what happens on default all need an attorney’s hand. The insurance side needs attention too. The buyer will need policies in its own name, and someone has to say in writing who answers for roofs finished before the handoff.

Real-World Scenario: A roofing owner receives interest from a national group but would rather the company stay local. The owner’s longtime operations manager wants to buy it and cannot pay the full price up front. They agree on a gradual sale, with an attorney drafting the payment terms and a CPA reviewing the tax treatment. The owner’s insurance agent sets up new policies for the buyer and helps both sides settle who answers for claims on work done before the change.

Passing the company to family

A son, daughter or other relative who has grown up in the business can take it over, by sale, by gift or through a mix of the two. The Small Business Administration notes that transferring ownership of a family business may have legal impacts, such as estate and gift tax obligations, which is why this path belongs with an estate attorney and a CPA from the start.

The practical work is the same as any other transfer. The family member needs authority, not only a title. Customers, general contractors and crews need to know who decides. Licenses and certificates may have to change hands, and the insurance program should show the right named insured and the right people as owners. The post on what drives a roofing business’s value is useful here too, because a family buyer deserves the same clear picture of the company that an outside buyer would demand.

Selling to a local or regional roofer

A respected competitor in your market, or a regional company that wants to enter it, can be a natural buyer. It knows the trade, it may already know your customers, and it can absorb your crews into work it understands. The trade-off is that a competitor may retire your name or merge your operation into its own.

Compare that path with a consolidator using the same questions about structure, payment, your role and the crew. The post on how to compare private equity and a competitor as buyers gives you a worksheet for that comparison.

Selling gradually, or leasing the business

A gradual sale moves ownership in stages. The Small Business Administration calls a gradual sale a flexible option for transferring a business. It also describes transferring ownership through a lease, under which you commit to a contract that details the conditions and are paid for temporarily giving up control of the company.

Both paths keep you connected to the company for longer, which can be the point. You stay close enough to protect what you built, and the new operator earns into the role. Both also keep you exposed for longer. If the operator runs the company poorly, your income and your name suffer with it. Write the insurance requirements into the contract: whose policies apply, who is named on them, and what proof of coverage the operator must give you.

Employee ownership through a stock ownership plan

An employee stock ownership plan lets employees own part or all of the company through a retirement plan. The Internal Revenue Service describes an ESOP as a qualified defined contribution plan that is a stock bonus plan or a stock bonus and money purchase plan. It also says an ESOP must invest primarily in qualifying employer securities, and that the Internal Revenue Service and the Department of Labor share jurisdiction over some of its features.

This path is complex and needs specialists in plan design, valuation and law. It can appeal to an owner who wants the crew to share in what it helped build. Ask your advisors whether the company’s size and earnings can support it before you spend money exploring it.

Exit paths for a roofing owner besides a national consolidator A stacked diagram of exit paths for a roofing owner other than a national consolidator. The top block is selling to people you know: a key employee, the management team or a family member. Below it is selling to a local roofer, such as a respected competitor or a regional company entering the market. Next is transferring over time through a gradual sale, a lease or employee stock ownership. The last block is keeping the company by selling a minority share or hiring a manager, or winding down cleanly. The closing band says every path needs an answer for roofs already finished. No figures or dollar amounts are shown. Exit paths besides a national consolidator Sell to people you know A key employee, your managers or a family member Sell to a local roofer A respected competitor or a regional company entering Transfer over time A gradual sale, a lease or employee stock ownership Keep it or close it Sell a minority share, hire a manager, or wind down cleanly Every path needs an answer for roofs already finished.
A national consolidator is a single exit among several, and every path still has to settle who answers for finished roofs.

Keeping the company and stepping back

Selling is not the only way to get your time back. You can sell a minority share to an investor or a partner and keep control. You can keep full ownership and hire a general manager to run the daily work while you move to an owner’s role. Either way, you keep the upside and the responsibility.

Stepping back works only when the company can run without you. That means a written estimating process, foremen who can make decisions on the roof, and a safety program that is enforced when you are not there. The posts on how to grow a roofing business and hiring and retaining roofing crews cover the building blocks. A peer group can help with the outside view an owner loses when nobody above you asks hard questions; the post on peer networks for roofing business owners explains how to find one. If your crew’s benefits are part of the reason you are wary of a consolidator, the post on employee benefits after a private equity sale explains what can change.

Closing the company in an orderly way

Sometimes the right exit is to finish the backlog and close. The Small Business Administration reminds owners to handle final returns for income tax and sales tax. It also warns that failure to legally dissolve an LLC or corporation with any state where you are registered will expose you to continued taxes.

For a roofer, closing has an extra wrinkle: your finished roofs outlast the company. A leak or failure can surface after you cancel your policies. The post on roof leaks and completed operations explains that exposure, and the general liability page covers the coverage involved. Before you cancel anything, ask your agent how claims on completed work would be handled and what options exist for that exposure.

Whatever path you take, the workers’ compensation record matters to whoever runs the operation next. The National Council on Compensation Insurance says that changes in ownership may affect the use of an individual employer’s experience. Tell your agent about any ownership change early, so the record follows the operation the way it should.

Questions to ask before you choose a path

Work through these with your advisors before you answer any buyer:

  • What do I want my role to be a year after the change, if I have one at all?
  • Who inside or near the company could run it, and could they buy it over time?
  • How would each path be taxed, and what does a CPA see as the after-tax result?
  • What security do I hold if a buyer pays me over time and stops paying?
  • Who answers for claims on roofs finished before the change?
  • What new policies, licenses and certificates does the next owner or operator need?
  • Does the company run well enough without me to support the path I want?

The Small Business Administration says its local assistance finder can connect you with local guidance in planning your exit strategy, and its Small Business Development Centers provide counseling and training to small businesses. Those can be good places to start before you pay for specialists. The post on how to prepare a roofing business for sale covers the records every path needs. For the insurance side of any of these options, start with the roofing insurance hub or the quote page. Sources: the Small Business Administration’s guide to closing or selling your business, the Small Business Administration’s page on Small Business Development Centers, the Internal Revenue Service’s installment sales publication, the Internal Revenue Service’s page on employee stock ownership plans and the National Council on Compensation Insurance’s experience rating primer. This post is general education, not legal, tax or investment advice.

The bottom line

A national consolidator is one buyer, not the only exit. A roofing owner can sell to a key employee or the management team, pass the company to family, sell to a local or regional roofer, sell gradually or lease the business, set up employee ownership, sell a minority share, hire a manager and step back, or close the company in an orderly way. Each path has its own financing, tax and insurance consequences, so work through them with an attorney, a CPA and your insurance agent before you commit. This post is general education, not legal, tax or investment advice.

Frequently asked questions

What are the alternatives to selling to a national roofing consolidator?

A roofing owner can sell to a key employee or management team, transfer the company to family, sell to a local or regional roofer, sell gradually or lease the business, set up an employee stock ownership plan, sell a minority share, or hire a manager and step back. Closing in an orderly way is also an option. Each path carries different financing, tax and insurance consequences.

How does consolidation affect independent roofers?

Consolidation adds better-funded competitors and new buyers to a market at the same time. An independent roofer can face rivals with central purchasing, formal safety programs and larger insurance programs when bidding commercial work and hiring crews. It also means more buyers may call. An owner who plans to stay independent can answer with local relationships, specialization and the same documented systems the larger groups rely on.

Can I sell my roofing company to an employee?

Yes, a key employee or management team can buy the company, and the price can be paid over time if the buyer cannot pay it all at closing. The Internal Revenue Service defines an installment sale as one where you receive at least one payment after the tax year of the sale. Have an attorney document the terms and the security for each payment before you hand over control.

What is an employee stock ownership plan?

An employee stock ownership plan is a type of retirement plan that holds company stock for employees. The Internal Revenue Service describes it as a qualified defined contribution plan that is a stock bonus plan or a stock bonus and money purchase plan, and says it must invest primarily in qualifying employer securities. Setting one up involves specialized legal, tax and valuation advice.

Can I lease my roofing business instead of selling it?

Yes, a lease is one of the ownership transfer options the Small Business Administration describes, alongside an outright sale and a gradual sale. Under a lease you commit to a contract that details the conditions, and you are paid for temporarily giving up control while someone else runs the business. The terms, the insurance and who answers for the work are all set in that contract, so have it drafted carefully.

What happens to my insurance if I close my roofing company instead of selling it?

Closing ends your active policies, but it does not end your exposure for roofs you already finished. A leak or failure can surface after the doors close. Before you cancel anything, ask your agent how claims on completed work would be handled and what options exist for that exposure. The Small Business Administration also reminds owners to handle final returns for income tax and sales tax.

About the author

Nate Jones, CPCU

Nate Jones, CPCU, is the founder of Wexford Insurance and Roofing Guard Insurance, a specialty insurance agency placing roofing contractor coverage in 48 states across a 16-carrier specialty panel. He insures roofing companies through every kind of ownership change, from a founder handing the keys to a foreman to a family transfer to a quiet wind-down, so he sees what each path asks of the policies, the certificates and the claims on finished roofs. This page maps the options and leaves price and tax structure to the advisors licensed to set them. Connect via the Roofing Guard Insurance quote form or call 317-942-0549.

Insure your roofing operation with a CPCU-led agency

Tell us how you work — residential steep-slope, commercial and industrial low-slope and torch-down, or specialty metal and tile — and we will market it to carriers that write the roofing class.