A roofing contractor’s workers’ compensation premium is built in steps. Payroll is sorted into classifications, each classification carries a rate, the results are added into a base premium, an experience modification can adjust that base, and a payroll audit reconciles the estimate to what happened. This post walks those steps and what each one means for an owner.
It carries no figures, because rates and classification tables are filed state by state and change. For the price picture across states, see the roofing insurance cost drivers pillar; for the coverage itself, the workers’ compensation page.
Step one: payroll is assigned to classifications
Start with how the rating system sees an employer. The National Council on Compensation Insurance explains that under manual rating, all employers are grouped according to their business operation or classification, and the rates are averages reflecting the normal conditions found in each classification. An employer is assigned to a classification so the rates reflect the cost of employers with similar characteristics.
Texas describes the mechanics plainly. Its insurance department says that employers are assigned one or more classifications based on the type of business, each employee’s payroll is then assigned to the appropriate classification, and the total payroll for each classification is multiplied by the company’s rate for that classification. The employer’s basic premium is the sum of the individual classification premiums.
California’s version has the same shape. Its insurance department explains that classification codes are developed and assigned by the Workers’ Compensation Insurance Rating Bureau of California and approved by the Insurance Commissioner, that payroll for each classification is estimated and multiplied by the applicable rate, and that the sum is the base premium. The base premium is then modified using rating plans and by experience modification.
Classification is about the business, then the work
The state agencies answer which code applies in terms of the business, not the task. Washington’s Department of Labor and Industries says its system classifies businesses according to their level of hazard or risk, and its employer guide says that generally it is the nature of business of the employer that is classified, not the separate occupations or operations of individual employees.
The same guide says that if the classifications assigned to a business do not appear correct, or the nature of the business changes, a change in risk classification may be required. Its example is a painting contractor that begins doing drywall, which would need a new classification. For a roofer that adds a new line of work, the lesson is the same: when the work changes, tell the insurer, because the classification follows the work.
This post does not list codes or rates. The classification manuals are published by the rating bodies, they differ by state, and the right assignment for your crews is a conversation with the agent or insurer that rates your policy. The residential roofing and commercial and industrial roofing pages describe how we approach each kind of work.
Payroll and the final audit
Because the rating basis is payroll, the estimate at the start of the policy is only an estimate. Texas’s Basic Manual says that all workers’ compensation policies are subject to a final payroll audit that reflects the actual payroll and the actual premium developed, in comparison to the estimated payrolls and premium calculated when the policy was issued.
California’s insurance department says the final premium cannot be calculated until the policy term is over and the payroll records have been audited. If payroll has gone up from the estimate, the employer owes additional premium; if it has gone down, the insurer owes a return premium. For a business whose crews grow for a storm job and shrink afterward, that reconciliation is where the estimate meets the year.
The owner’s part is records. Washington’s guide says accurate, properly maintained records minimize the time needed for an accurate review in case of an audit. Washington’s state fund works from reported worker hours rather than dollars, so the rating basis itself differs by state, and its published example prices each classification per hour worked.
Experience rating: your record against the class average
The experience modification is where an individual contractor’s history enters. NCCI’s guide says experience rating compares the experience of an individual employer with the average employer in the same classification. The result is a modification based on individual payroll and loss records that may increase, decrease or leave premium unchanged. An employer with better-than-average loss experience generally receives a credit; worse-than-average carries a debit.
The plan’s design choices shape how a roofer should think about claims. The plan gives greater weight to accident frequency than severity, and it splits each loss into a primary portion that reflects frequency and an excess portion that reflects severity. A state accident limitation also caps how much of any single loss counts, because NCCI says including the entire portion of a very large loss reduces the predictive ability of the plan. NCCI illustrates the effect: an employer with many small losses can receive a much higher modification than an employer with one large loss of the same total.
The guide also says the experience period excludes the current policy, because the modification is calculated during the current term from earlier, valued policy years. And it says larger employers’ modifications are more heavily influenced by their own experience, while a small employer’s is tempered. Medical-only claims count at a reduced weight in most states, which the guide ties to discouraging employers from paying such claims without reporting them.
Claims handling and return to work
Because the loss record is the input, how claims are handled reaches the premium. NCCI’s guide says the plan includes an incentive for employers to reduce the frequency of losses, as well as an incentive to enable injured employees to return to work as soon as reasonably possible, and that employer involvement can reduce the severity of losses once they have occurred.
Washington’s guide takes the same line from the state side. It says preventing an injury is the most effective way to protect employees and limit the financial impact of claims, and that an employer should have a system to manage a claim if one occurs, including investigating any accident or near miss. For the owner’s side of that discipline, see how to reduce liability and comp claims in roofing, the OSHA fall protection post, and the falls from height post for how a fall loss moves through the system.
Not every state uses the same plan
Everything above describes a framework, and the framework varies. NCCI says its experience rating plan does not apply in California, Delaware, Michigan, New Jersey, New York or Pennsylvania, nor in the state-fund states of North Dakota, Ohio, Washington and Wyoming, which administer their own plans and rates. California’s insurance department explains that the rating bureau calculates experience modifications from payroll and loss information insurers submit annually.
Washington shows the state-fund version. Its premium rate is based on the risk classifications assigned to the business, the base rates for each, and the business’s experience factor. The department says a factor above the neutral point raises rates above the base and a factor below it lowers them, and that new businesses start at the neutral point until they become experience rated. For the legal side of each state, read roofing workers’ comp by state.
Real-World Scenario: Picture a pair of roofing contractors doing the same work and carrying policies from the same market. At audit, one produces payroll records organized by the work performed and by crew; the other reconstructs them from a ledger. Both end up with a correct final premium, but one spends the audit explaining a document and the other answering questions about a number. Over the next renewal cycles, the first reports every incident promptly and keeps injured crew members in modified duties when a physician allows it; the second lets small claims drift. Neither owner changed the rate for the classification. They changed the record the rating plan reads.
When ownership or operations change
Changes in the work or in ownership deserve a call to the insurer before renewal. When the work changes, such as adding a new service line, classification may change with it. When ownership changes, NCCI’s guide says the employer must notify the insurance provider in writing within a set period, that recalculation of modifications may be required, and that a change in ownership can affect the use of an employer’s experience. Washington’s guide says that when an employer buys an existing business and continues the same operations, the business’s existing experience rating is in most cases transferred to the new owner.
Related reading: how Houston roofing workers’ comp premiums are built, how to lower roofing insurance cost without gaps and what underwriters ask for in a quote.
That is why a sale or acquisition belongs in the conversation with your agent early; the how to sell a roofing business guide covers what a transaction surfaces on the insurance side. When you are ready to talk through your own payroll and classifications, start a quote, and for crews you are adding, see hiring and retaining roofing crews. The premium is built in steps, and an owner who can read the steps can ask the right question at renewal.