Coverage Explained

Who Offers Workers’ Comp for Roofing Contractors?

Two roofers working up a roof slope where dark shingles meet white underlayment

Workers’ comp for roofing contractors comes from private insurers that write the roofing class, from a state fund in the states that run one, and from a market of last resort when no private insurer will offer a policy. Which door is open to you depends on the state and on your record.

Where a roofer’s workers’ comp comes from

There is no single list of companies that insure roofers, and this post names none. What exists is a structure. In a state with a private market, insurers decide which classes of business they want, and some of them want roofing. In a state that runs its own fund, the fund is the source. And where a private market exists but no insurer in it will take a particular employer, the state provides a fallback.

Knowing which structure you are in saves time. A roofer in Ohio who calls private insurers for workers’ compensation is asking the wrong people, and a roofer in California who has been declined once has options left. The workers’ compensation coverage page explains the policy itself, and the post on roofing workers’ comp by state compares the systems.

Private insurers that write roofing

In a private-market state, the first source is an insurer that has chosen to write the roofing class. Roofing is work at height, and an insurer has to be willing to take the injuries that come with it. An insurer that is not willing declines every roofer who applies, and that decline says nothing about your company.

The insurers that do write the class each have their own view of it. One may prefer residential re-roofing, another commercial low-slope work, another only contractors with an established history. This is where the person placing your coverage matters. An agent with access to several of those insurers can send your file to the ones whose appetite fits. The post on roofing insurance brokers and agents explains how that access differs.

A new roofing company meets the same market with less to show. With no loss history, the underwriter relies on the owner’s experience in the trade, the planned work and the safety practices in place from the first day. Say so plainly in the submission. An honest file from a new company gets a clearer answer than a vague file from an established one.

State funds: where the state is the insurer

In some states the private market is not an option for workers’ compensation. The National Council on Compensation Insurance describes North Dakota, Ohio, Washington and Wyoming as monopolistic states that administer their own plans and rates. A roofing contractor with crews there applies to the state fund.

The other policies still come from the private market. A roofer in one of those states buys general liability, commercial auto and equipment coverage from private insurers and deals with the fund for the crew. The post on being a licensed and insured roofing contractor in Ohio shows how that split works in practice. Each fund publishes its own application process and its own rules for classification and reporting, so a roofer who moves into one of those states should start with the fund’s website instead of an insurer’s.

The market of last resort

A private-market state still has to answer for the employer nobody wants. The mechanism differs by state. In California, the Department of Insurance describes State Fund as a state-operated entity that competes with private insurers and operates as the insurer of last resort if private companies are not willing to offer workers’ compensation coverage. The department also says a commercial broker-agent can provide information regarding State Fund and self-insurance.

Other states use their own arrangements, sometimes called assigned risk plans, and this post does not describe each one. Ask your agent what your state uses, or ask the state insurance department. The point for an owner is that a decline from the private market is not the end of the search. It is the point at which the fallback applies. The California post and the Los Angeles post cover that state in detail.

Texas: the employer’s choice

Texas adds a different question. The Texas Department of Insurance says private employers can choose whether to provide workers’ compensation insurance coverage. An employer that chooses not to is called a non-subscriber, and the department’s non-subscriber page describes what follows from that choice.

For a Texas roofer, “who offers workers’ comp” therefore comes after “will I carry it.” A contract, a general contractor or a public job can require the coverage whatever the statute allows. The post on roofing workers’ comp rates in Houston and the Texas location page cover the Texas picture. Make the decision with an advisor and an attorney.

Real-World Scenario: A roofing owner with recent injury claims is declined by the insurer that has written the account for years. The owner assumes no one will offer coverage. The agent asks for the loss runs and learns that the claims came from a single crew that worked without a tie-off plan. The owner writes a fall protection program, retrains that crew and documents it. The agent sends the file to other roofing insurers with that explanation attached, and keeps the state’s market of last resort as the fallback.

Why roofers get declined, and what changes the answer

A decline has one of two causes. Either the insurer does not write roofing, or something in your file gave the underwriter a reason to pass. Ask your agent which it was, because only the second is something you can work on.

The file reasons are familiar. A pattern of claims with no explanation. No written safety program. Payroll that does not match the work described. Subcontractors with no certificates on file. Each has a fix. The post on how to reduce liability and comp claims covers the claims side, and the post on OSHA fall protection for roofing contractors covers the program an underwriter will ask about. The National Council on Compensation Insurance says experience rating gives employers some influence over the premium they pay and an incentive to develop loss prevention and claims management programs.

Where workers’ comp for a roofing contractor comes from A stacked diagram of where workers’ compensation for a roofing contractor comes from. A private insurer that chooses to write the roofing class is the first source. A state fund is the source in the states that run their own plans and rates. A market of last resort applies when no private insurer offers a policy. The closing band says the state and the contractor’s record decide which applies. No figures or dollar amounts are shown. Where a roofer’s workers’ comp comes from Private insurer An insurer that chooses to write the roofing class State fund In the states that run their own plans and rates Market of last resort When no private insurer offers a policy Your state and your record decide which applies.
Workers’ comp for a roofer comes from a private insurer, a state fund or a market of last resort, depending on the state and the account.

What an underwriter asks before offering a policy

Whoever the source is, the questions are similar. An underwriter can ask for payroll by classification and by state, a description of the roofing you do, loss runs for recent years, how you use subcontractors, and what your safety practices are. The National Association of Insurance Commissioners says workers’ compensation premiums may be based on broad factors such as payroll and type of work performed. How payroll is sorted into classes is covered in roofing workers’ comp class codes.

Answer once, in writing, and use the same answers everywhere. The post on workers’ comp costs for roofers explains how the premium is built from those facts, and the post on falls from height explains the claim the policy exists for.

Gutters, demolition and other trades asking the same question

Owners in neighboring trades search for the same answer, and the structure is the same for them: private insurers, state funds where the state runs one, and a market of last resort. What changes is the classification and which insurers want it. Gutter crews can read workers’ comp for gutter installation contractors.

A company that does roofing and something else should describe each operation and its payroll separately. Texas’s insurance department explains that each employee’s payroll is assigned to the appropriate classification, and an underwriter prices each classification on its own. Blending roofing payroll with lower-hazard work, or the reverse, produces a quote that will not survive the audit. Describe the work as it is.

How to get placed

  • Ask your agent which insurers write roofing workers’ compensation in your state, and how many will see your file.
  • If you were declined, ask whether the reason was the class or your account.
  • Put your safety program, training records and return-to-work practice in writing.
  • Request loss runs early and prepare a short explanation of each claim.
  • Collect a current certificate from every subcontractor before the submission goes out.
  • Ask what your state’s market of last resort is and what applying to it involves.

To have your account reviewed, use the quote page, and see the roofing insurance hub for how workers’ compensation fits with the rest of the coverage. Sources: the National Council on Compensation Insurance’s experience rating primer, the California Department of Insurance’s workers’ compensation guide, the Texas Department of Insurance’s non-subscriber page and rate guide, and the National Association of Insurance Commissioners’ small business page. This post is general education, not legal or tax advice.

The bottom line

Workers’ comp for roofing contractors comes from private insurers that write the roofing class, from a state fund in the states that run one, and from a market of last resort when no private insurer will offer a policy. Which one applies depends on your state and your record. An agent who places roofing can tell you which is open to you, and a complete file with payroll by role, loss runs and a written safety program is what moves a roofer from a decline to an offer. This is general education, not legal or tax advice.

Frequently asked questions

Who offers workers’ compensation insurance for roofing contractors?

Private insurers that write the roofing class, state funds in the states that operate one, and a market of last resort for employers no private insurer will cover. Which applies depends on the state where your crews work. An agent who places roofing regularly can tell you which insurers are quoting the class in your state and what each needs before it will offer a policy.

Where can I place a roofer for workers’ comp after a decline?

Start by asking why the insurer declined, then fix what can be fixed in the file. A different private insurer may view the account differently. If none will offer coverage, ask your agent about your state’s market of last resort. The California Department of Insurance describes State Fund as the insurer of last resort if private companies are not willing to offer coverage.

Which states make roofers buy workers’ comp from the state?

The National Council on Compensation Insurance describes North Dakota, Ohio, Washington and Wyoming as monopolistic states that administer their own plans and rates. A roofing contractor with crews in one of those states applies to the state fund for workers’ compensation and places general liability, auto and other policies in the private market. Check the fund’s own rules for your situation.

Can a Texas roofing contractor go without workers’ comp?

The Texas Department of Insurance says private employers can choose whether to provide workers’ compensation insurance coverage. That choice carries consequences the department describes on its non-subscriber page, and a contract or a public job can still require the coverage. Treat it as a decision to make with an advisor and an attorney, not as a default.

Why do insurers decline roofing contractors for workers’ comp?

An insurer can decline because it does not write the class at all, or because of something in the file: a history of claims, no written safety program, payroll that does not match the work described, or subcontractors with no certificates. The first reason has nothing to do with you. The second can be worked on, and your agent can tell you which it was.

Does the same answer apply to gutter installers and other high-hazard trades?

The sources are the same: private insurers, state funds where the state runs one, and a market of last resort. What changes is the classification and which insurers want it. A company that does both roofing and gutter work should describe each operation and its payroll separately, because the way payroll is assigned to classifications affects who will quote and on what terms.

About the author

Nate Jones, CPCU

Nate Jones, CPCU, is the founder of Wexford Insurance and Roofing Guard Insurance, a specialty insurance agency placing roofing contractor coverage in 48 states across a 16-carrier specialty panel. He places workers’ compensation for roofing contractors, including owners who have already been declined once, so he knows which markets take the class and what each one asks to see. This page maps where the coverage comes from and keeps to what the state agencies and the national rating organization publish. Connect via the Roofing Guard Insurance quote form or call 317-942-0549.

Insure your roofing operation with a CPCU-led agency

Tell us how you work — residential steep-slope, commercial and industrial low-slope and torch-down, or specialty metal and tile — and we will market it to carriers that write the roofing class.