Owner Resources

Roofing Insurance Broker or Agent: Who Should Place Your Coverage?

A roofing crew working across new plywood decking on a large roof, seen from above

A roofing contractor can buy coverage through an independent agent or broker who can approach several insurers, or through an agent who represents a single company. The practical difference is how many underwriters see your application, and for a class as specialized as roofing that can decide whether you get a workable quote.

Agent, broker, company: what each word means

In everyday use, an agent represents one or more insurers, and a broker works on behalf of the buyer. A company’s own agent sells that company’s policies and no one else’s. An independent agent holds appointments with several insurers and can offer any of them. A broker searches the market for the buyer and may reach insurers that an agent cannot approach directly.

States license these roles and define them in their own ways, and one person or agency can hold more than one license. The National Association of Insurance Commissioners publishes a glossary that covers the terms. For a roofing owner the label on the door matters less than two practical questions: which insurers can this person take your application to, and do those insurers want roofing?

Why the number of markets matters for roofing

Roofing is a class an insurer can decline, or accept only on narrow terms. Work at height, flame-applied systems and long-lived completed work are each a reason an underwriter might pass. A contractor who applies to one insurer gets one answer. If that answer is no, or yes with an exclusion for part of the work, the search starts over.

An agent or broker with access to several markets can send the same file to each underwriter who writes the class and return with the answers side by side. The Small Business Administration advises comparing rates, terms and benefits for insurance offers from several agents, and a multi-market agent does part of that comparison inside one office. The roofing insurance hub describes the coverage those markets are quoting.

What a roofing specialist does differently

A specialist builds the file the way a roofing underwriter wants to read it. That means payroll split by role, a description of the roof systems and heights, an explanation of each past claim, and the subcontractor paperwork in order before the submission goes out. The Small Business Administration says commercial insurance agents can help you find policies that match your business needs, and for a roofer the match depends on that presentation.

A specialist also knows where the policies have to agree. The general liability form, the workers’ compensation policy, the commercial auto policy and the umbrella each start from a description of your work, and a mismatch between them is a gap. The post on how to get a roofing insurance quote lists what a well-built file contains, and the post on roofing contractors insurance programs explains what it means when the lines are placed together.

Buying direct from one company

An insurer can sell through its own agents or directly to the buyer. That route can work for a roofer when the company writes the class, offers each line you need and has terms you have read. A long relationship with one company’s agent has value, especially at claim time.

The limit is that you see one set of terms. If the company stops writing roofing in your state, changes its conditions at renewal or declines the commercial work you just won, you have no second offer waiting. Ask a single-company agent what happens to an account when the company’s appetite changes, and whether the agent can place the lines the company will not write.

Real-World Scenario: A roofing contractor has bought every policy from the same single-company agent for years. The company then stops offering liability coverage for flame-applied roofing, which is a large share of the contractor’s commercial work. The agent has no other insurer to offer. The owner takes the account to an independent agency, which sends one submission to several roofing underwriters and returns with offers that include the torch work. The first agent did nothing wrong; the structure gave the owner one door.

How the person placing your coverage is paid

Ask how your agent or broker is paid, and expect a direct answer. Compensation can come as a commission from the insurer, as a fee you pay, or as a mix, and the arrangement can differ by state and by policy. You are entitled to understand it before you sign.

The reason to ask is not suspicion. It is that you want to know what the person is being paid to do during the year: issue certificates, review contracts, report payroll changes, help at audit and stand beside you at a claim. Service that ends when the policy is issued is a poor bargain for a roofing company, whose certificate requests and contract reviews continue all season.

“Roofing insurance near me”: does local matter?

The agent has to be licensed in the states where you work. That matters more than the distance between your offices. Applications, certificates and claim reports move by phone and email, and a specialist in another city can serve a roofing account well.

What you should expect is local knowledge. Workers’ compensation differs by state, licensing differs by state, and weather exposures differ by region. The post on roofing workers’ comp by state and the locations page show how much changes at a state line. Ask an agent how they handle a certificate request that arrives while your crew is waiting at a gate, because that is the service a roofer feels.

Who can take a roofing contractor’s application to which insurers A stacked diagram of who sees a roofing contractor’s insurance application. The contractor writes a description of the work. A single-company agent takes the file to that company’s underwriter. An independent agent or broker takes the same file to several underwriters who write roofing. The closing band says to compare the forms and the terms, not only the price. No figures or dollar amounts are shown. Who sees your roofing application Your roofing company A written description of the work you do Single-company agent The file goes to that company’s underwriter Independent agent or broker The same file goes to several underwriters who write roofing Compare the forms and the terms, not only the price.
The difference between a single-company agent and an independent agent or broker is how many roofing underwriters see your file.

How to check who you are dealing with

Ask for the license number and confirm it with your state insurance department, which licenses agents and brokers. The Small Business Administration lists finding a reputable licensed agent among its steps to buy business insurance. If your crews cross state lines, confirm the license in each state.

Then test the experience. Ask how many roofing contractors the agency places and what kinds of roofing they do. Ask for an example of a claim the agency helped a roofer through, with the details removed. The answers do not need to be impressive. They need to be specific.

Ask about claims as well. When a worker is hurt or a customer reports a leak, the agent is the first call, and what happens next depends on how the agency is set up. Find out who takes that call, how the claim is reported to the insurer and whether anyone follows it afterward. The about page describes who is behind this agency, and you should expect the same openness from anyone who wants your account.

Switching agents, and avoiding a tangle

You can change who represents you. The time to do it cleanly is ahead of renewal, with enough room for the new agent to build the file and approach the markets. Ask both the old agent and the new one how the handoff works for policies already in force.

One caution applies while you shop. If several agents approach the same underwriter for the same contractor with different descriptions of the business, the underwriter sees a file nobody checked. Give every agent the same written description, the same payroll and the same loss runs, and ask each one which insurers they plan to approach. The post on cheap roofing contractor insurance explains why the lowest quote from a rushed search can hide a gap.

Questions to ask before you choose

  • How many roofing contractors do you place, and what kinds of roofing?
  • Which insurers will you approach for my account, and why those?
  • What written description of my operations will every underwriter receive?
  • How are you paid, and what service does that include during the year?
  • How fast are certificates issued, and who answers when I call from a job?
  • Who helps me when a claim is reported, and what do you do at the premium audit?
  • Will you show me the exclusions and subcontractor conditions on each quoted form?

When you are ready to have several markets review your company, use the quote page. If timing is the pressure, read how fast you can get roofing insurance first. Sources: the Small Business Administration’s business insurance guide, the National Association of Insurance Commissioners’ glossary of insurance terms and its small business page, and the Insurance Information Institute’s small business insurance basics. This post is general education, not legal or tax advice.

The bottom line

A roofing contractor can buy coverage through an independent agent or broker who can approach several insurers, or through an agent who represents one company. For a class as specialized as roofing, the number of underwriters who see your application, and how well it is presented, can decide whether you get a workable quote. Choose the person who places roofing regularly, can name the markets they will approach, and will show you the forms as well as the price. Confirm the license with your state insurance department. This is general education, not legal or tax advice.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between a roofing insurance broker and an agent?

In everyday use, an agent represents one or more insurers and a broker works on behalf of the buyer, but states license and define the roles in their own ways, and one person can hold both. For a roofing owner the practical question is narrower: how many insurers that write roofing can this person take your application to, and how well do they present it?

Should a roofing contractor use an independent agent?

An independent agent or broker can take one application to several insurers, which matters in a class an insurer can decline. An agent for a single company can offer only that company’s answer. Either can serve a roofer well if the insurer behind the quote wants roofing. Ask which markets will see your account before you decide, and compare the forms as well as the price.

Does my roofing insurance agent need to be near me?

The agent needs to be licensed in the states where you work, and that matters more than distance. Applications, certificates and claims reports move by phone and email. What you should expect locally is knowledge of your state’s workers’ compensation system and licensing rules. Ask how fast certificates are issued and who answers when you call during a job.

How do I check that an insurance agent or broker is licensed?

Ask for the license number and confirm it with your state insurance department, which licenses agents and brokers. The Small Business Administration advises finding a reputable licensed agent as one of its steps to buy business insurance. If your crews work in several states, ask whether the agent is licensed in each one, because a license in one state does not carry into another.

Can I buy roofing insurance directly from an insurance company?

An insurer can sell through its own agents or directly, and that route can work when the insurer writes roofing and offers every line you need. The limit is that you see one company’s terms. If that company declines your class or excludes part of your work, you have to start again elsewhere. Ask what happens to your account if the company’s appetite changes.

What should I ask a roofing insurance broker before I sign?

Ask how many roofing accounts they place, which insurers they will approach for yours, what written description of your operations they will use, how they are paid, how certificates are issued, and who handles a claim. Then ask to see the exclusions and subcontractor conditions on the quoted forms. A specialist answers those without hesitation and in specifics.

About the author

Nate Jones, CPCU

Nate Jones, CPCU, is the founder of Wexford Insurance and Roofing Guard Insurance, a specialty insurance agency placing roofing contractor coverage in 48 states across a 16-carrier specialty panel. He runs an independent agency that places roofing contractors with a panel of insurers, so he works on the side of the desk this page describes. He wrote it so an owner can ask any agent or broker, including him, the questions that separate a roofing specialist from a generalist. Connect via the Roofing Guard Insurance quote form or call 317-942-0549.

Insure your roofing operation with a CPCU-led agency

Tell us how you work — residential steep-slope, commercial and industrial low-slope and torch-down, or specialty metal and tile — and we will market it to carriers that write the roofing class.