Compare a private equity offer and a competitor’s offer on the same worksheet: what is being bought, how and when you are paid, what you will do afterward, what happens to the crew and the name, and who answers for the roofs you already finished. The headline price is only one line on that sheet.
Why the two buyers read your company differently
A competing roofer and a private-equity-backed platform can look at the same books and see different things. The competitor knows your market, your crews and possibly your customers. It is buying capacity it can put to work under its own systems, and it can judge your operation quickly because it runs the same kind of business. A platform is assembling a larger group, and it is buying a local company it may keep intact, with you in charge of it for a defined period.
Those different goals show up in the terms, not only in the price. The post on who buys roofing businesses describes the buyer types, and the post on whether to partner with a platform or stay independent covers what working life looks like inside a group. This post is narrower. You already have interest from both kinds of buyer, or expect to, and you need a fair way to put the offers next to each other.
What exactly is being bought
Start with the object of the sale, because everything else follows from it. A buyer can purchase the company’s assets, such as trucks, equipment, contracts, the name and goodwill, or it can purchase the ownership of the entity itself. The Internal Revenue Service says the sale of a trade or business for a lump sum is considered a sale of each individual asset rather than of a single asset. The Small Business Administration’s tax guidance says sellers like to sell the stock to limit tax reporting to capital gain, and that buyers prefer an asset sale because it creates higher basis for the depreciable assets they acquire.
The choice matters past the tax return. In a sale of the entity, the buyer steps into the company as it stands, along with its history. In an asset sale, the old entity can remain with you, and with it whatever obligations the agreement leaves behind. Ask each buyer which structure it intends and why. A competitor and a platform may have different reasons for preferring one, and your CPA can tell you what each version means for you.
How and when the money arrives
Two offers with the same headline can pay out very differently. Part of the price can arrive at closing, part can be paid over time, and part can depend on how the business performs after the sale. A platform can also offer a share in the larger group in place of some cash, which ties part of your payment to a company you will no longer control.
The Small Business Administration says that selling a business in full transfers ownership immediately and pays you right away, and it calls a gradual sale a flexible option for transferring a business. The Internal Revenue Service says an installment sale is a sale of property where you receive at least one payment after the tax year of the sale. The Small Business Administration’s tax guidance adds that there is always a risk in an installment arrangement that the buyer will default. When you compare offers, separate the money you receive at closing from the money you are being promised, and ask what secures each promised payment.
Your role after closing
A competitor may want you for a short handoff and then out of the way, because it already has leadership. A platform may want you to keep running your location for a set term, with targets attached. Neither is wrong, but they describe different years of your life.
Read the role the way you would read a job offer. Who will you report to, which decisions stay with you, how long is the commitment, and what happens to the deferred part of your price if you leave early or are asked to leave? The Small Business Administration’s tax guidance notes that a seller can consider negotiating a consulting agreement with the buyer, which is one way a continuing role is written down. Whatever the form, the role should be in the agreement, not in a handshake.
Real-World Scenario: A roofing owner receives an offer from a larger competitor across town and a second offer from a regional platform. The competitor’s offer pays more at closing and asks the owner to stay through a short transition. The platform’s offer pays part of the price later and asks the owner to keep running the company. The owner lays both on a single page and sees that the larger closing payment comes with a buyer who plans to retire the company name. The owner decides with advisors which terms matter more.
The crew, the name and the customers
Your crew is part of what each buyer is paying for, and the two buyers can have different plans for it. A competitor may merge your crews into its own, change foremen, or move people to its jobs. A platform may leave your crews in place and change pay structures, benefits or safety programs over time. Ask each buyer what happens to wages, titles and benefits at closing and after. The post on employee benefits after a private equity sale covers the benefit questions in detail, and the post on hiring and retaining roofing crews explains why a crew that walks takes value with it.
The name carries your reviews, your warranties and the trust your repeat customers place in it. A competitor may retire it. A platform may keep it as a local brand. Ask, and get the answer in writing, because your customers will hold the name responsible for roofs you installed under it.
The insurance file and the roofs you already finished
Every roof you have installed is still an exposure after the sale. A leak that shows up later can lead to a claim, and someone has to answer for it. The post on roof leaks and completed operations explains why finished work stays on the books. Ask each buyer, in writing, who handles claims on work completed before closing and which policy is expected to respond.
The workers’ compensation record is part of the same conversation. The National Council on Compensation Insurance says that when ownership changes, the employer must notify the insurance provider in writing within a set period, that recalculation of mods may be required, and that changes in ownership may affect the use of an employer’s experience. A competitor with its own record and a platform with a group program can treat your experience differently. The post on what drives roofing workers’ comp costs explains why that record matters, and the workers’ compensation page covers the coverage itself.
How diligence differs between the two buyers
A competitor may move quickly and rely on what it already knows about the trade. A platform backed by investors may run a longer, more formal review with outside accountants and lawyers. Either one will ask for the books, the contracts, the crew list and the insurance file, and either one can lower its price or change its terms because of what it finds.
The Small Business Administration says you must prepare a sales agreement to sell your business officially, and that you should not leave out any assets and liabilities, or this can create problems even after the sale has been finalized. It also says to note all adjustments, broker fees and any other aspects relevant to the terms of agreement. The post on how to prepare a roofing business for sale walks the preparation step by step. If you are still deciding whether to sell to either buyer at all, the post on alternatives to a national consolidator lays out other paths.
Questions to ask each buyer before you choose
Ask both buyers the same questions, in writing, so the answers line up:
- Are you buying the assets or the company itself, and why?
- How much of the price is paid at closing, and what secures the rest?
- What role do you expect me to fill, for how long, and what happens if it ends early?
- What happens to wages, titles and benefits for my crew on the first day and after?
- Will you keep the company name, and who honors the warranties I have issued?
- Who answers for claims on roofs finished before closing?
- What do you need from my insurance file, and when?
Answers that arrive vague are answers too. A buyer who cannot say what happens to your crew or your finished work has not thought about it yet, and the agreement is the place to make it think.
Who helps you compare
Put the offers in front of advisors before you favor one. The Small Business Administration says an attorney should review the sales agreement to make sure it is accurate and comprehensive. Its tax guidance says a sale of a business is a highly complex matter from a legal and tax perspective and advises against proceeding without expert advice. A CPA can compare the after-tax result of each structure, and an attorney can tell you what the deferred payments and role commitments really bind you to. The posts on what a roofing business is worth and SDE versus EBITDA explain the earnings measures each buyer will use.
Bring your insurance agent in at the same stage. The agent can pull loss runs, explain what each structure does to your policies, and raise the question of finished work while it can still shape the price. If you want to talk through your insurance file before a buyer reads it, use the quote page. Sources: the Small Business Administration’s guide to closing or selling your business, the Small Business Administration’s tax strategies for selling a business, the Internal Revenue Service’s sale of a business page, the Internal Revenue Service’s installment sales publication and the National Council on Compensation Insurance’s experience rating primer. This post is general education, not legal, tax or investment advice.