If your roofing crew includes employees, plan on carrying workers’ comp. Missouri and Arizona require it of employers with even a small crew, while Texas lets private employers choose and attaches duties to that choice. Subcontractors and owners are separate questions, and each state answers them on its own terms.
The answer starts with your state
Workers’ compensation is state law, so the first question is where your crews work, not how big the company is. The two state systems covered in detail below both reach a roofing company with a modest crew. Missouri’s Department of Labor and Industrial Relations says construction industry employers are required to carry workers’ compensation insurance if they have one or more employees. The Industrial Commission of Arizona says it is mandatory for employers to secure workers’ compensation insurance for their employees, and that the employer is required to carry it regardless of the number of workers.
Other states draw their own lines, and a roofing company that crosses a state line takes on that state’s rule for the work there. The post on roofing workers’ comp by state compares the systems, and the state posts on Missouri roofers and Phoenix shingle roofers go deeper on those two. The workers’ compensation coverage page explains what the policy itself pays for.
Employees: who counts on a roofing crew
The word employee is wider than the full-time roofer on salary. Missouri’s Department of Labor and Industrial Relations says the statutory definition of employee includes both full and part-time employees. A helper who works only on busy weeks, a relative who runs material on Saturdays and a laborer hired for a single tear-off can all fall inside that definition.
That is the reason to treat headcount loosely and payroll carefully. Count everyone you pay to work on or around the roof, then ask your agent whether each one belongs on the policy. A roofer who leaves the seasonal helpers off the payroll report is not saving premium. He is building a gap that shows up when one of those helpers falls, or when the auditor compares the policy with the bank records.
Classification follows the same logic. The code on your policy describes the work the payroll pays for, and a crew on the roof belongs in the roofing classification. The post on roofing workers’ comp class codes explains how that code is chosen.
Subcontractors: when their workers become yours
Hiring a subcontractor does not always move the injury risk off your books. Missouri’s statute says a person who has work done under contract on or about his premises, as part of his usual business, shall be deemed an employer and shall be liable under the workers’ compensation chapter to the contractor, his subcontractors and their employees when injured on or about those premises. The same section says the liability of the immediate employer shall be primary, and that of the others secondary in their order.
Arizona’s statute reaches a similar place by a different road. When an employer procures work from a contractor over whose work it retains supervision or control, the statute treats the contractor and the contractor’s employees, and any subcontractor and the subcontractor’s employees, as employees of the original employer.
For a roofing company, the practical answer is the same in both states. Before a subcontractor’s crew sets a ladder, get a current certificate showing that the subcontractor carries its own workers’ compensation, and keep it on file with the dates visible. If that policy is in force, it answers first. If it is not, the question of who pays can come back to you. The post on what insurance GCs require from roofing subs shows the same paperwork from the general contractor’s side.
Independent contractor or employee
Calling someone a subcontractor does not make him one. The Internal Revenue Service says the general rule is that an individual is an independent contractor if the person for whom the services are performed has the right to control or direct only the result of the work. That is the federal tax test, and workers’ compensation laws apply their own.
Arizona spells out one way to document the relationship for workers’ compensation. Its statute lets a business and an independent contractor prove the relationship by executing a written agreement, and says the agreement shall evidence that the business does not have the authority to supervise or control the actual work. The statute lists further conditions the agreement has to state.
A roofer who sets the hours, supplies the tools, directs the crew on the roof and pays by the square is describing an employee in practice, whatever the paperwork says. If you are unsure about a particular worker, ask your agent and an attorney before the season starts. The answer affects your payroll report, your audit and your exposure if that worker is hurt.
Owners, partners and LLC members
Owners raise a separate question, and the answer turns on the state and on how the business is organized. Missouri’s Department of Labor and Industrial Relations says sole proprietors and partners are not themselves covered unless they elect to be covered, and that close family member-employees and members of limited liability companies are presumed to be covered unless they opt out. The same answer includes executive officers of a corporation within the statutory definition of employee.
Arizona’s statute addresses sole proprietors who work for other businesses. It says a business that uses the services of a sole proprietor who has waived the sole proprietor’s rights is not liable for workers’ compensation coverage or the payment of premiums for that sole proprietor. A waiver like that answers a narrow question, and a roofing owner should ask the insurer and an attorney how it applies before relying on one.
Whether an owner should be on the policy is a business decision as well as a legal one. An owner who works on the roof every day has the same fall exposure as the crew, and a policy that excludes him leaves his own injury to his health insurance and savings. The post on how to start a roofing business covers the other choices an owner makes in the first year.
Real-World Scenario: A roofing owner runs a small company as a single-member LLC, works on every job and pays two helpers by the day in cash during the busy season. The owner assumes the helpers are contractors and that he is not covered himself. After a helper is hurt on a steep pitch, the owner learns that his state counts part-time workers as employees and that his own status depended on an election he never looked at. An owner who had listed every worker and asked the agent about owner coverage at the start would have known where he stood.
Texas: a choice with duties attached
Texas works differently. The Texas Department of Insurance says private employers in Texas can choose whether to provide workers’ compensation insurance coverage. It adds that employers that do not provide coverage must notify their workers, by posting a notice at the worksite and giving new employees written notice.
For a Texas roofer, the choice can be narrower than it looks. A general contractor, a property manager or a public job can require workers’ compensation in the contract, whatever the statute allows. The post on roofing workers’ comp rates in Houston covers the cost side of that decision. Make the decision with an advisor and an attorney.
What going without can cost
Skipping coverage you are required to carry is a legal problem, and skipping coverage you are allowed to skip is still a financial one. Missouri’s Department of Labor and Industrial Relations says exempt employers that decide not to purchase workers’ compensation insurance or self-insure remain potentially exposed to civil lawsuits brought by employees who are injured during work. In other words, even the employer the law does not require to insure can still answer for the injury.
For a roofing company, a single fall can be the claim that decides whether the business survives. The falls from height post explains that claim. The post on who offers workers’ comp for roofing contractors explains where to find a policy if you have been declined, and the post on being an insured roofing contractor explains how to prove coverage once it is in place.
Questions to ask your agent before the season
- Which states will my crews work in this year, and what does each require of a roofing employer?
- Who on my payroll, including part-time, seasonal and family workers, belongs on the policy?
- Which of my subcontractors have a current certificate on file, and how are uninsured subs treated at audit?
- Does anyone I treat as an independent contractor look like an employee under my state’s rules?
- Am I, as the owner, covered or excluded, and what choices does my state allow?
- If I work in Texas, what does each contract I sign require?
To have your crew and your policy reviewed, use the quote page, and see the roofing insurance hub for how workers’ compensation fits with the rest of your coverage. Sources: the Missouri Department of Labor and Industrial Relations’ answer on who must carry coverage, Missouri’s statute on contractors and subcontractors, the Industrial Commission of Arizona’s employer questions, Arizona’s statute on employers subject to the law, the Texas Department of Insurance’s non-subscriber page and the Internal Revenue Service’s independent contractor page. This post is general education, not legal or tax advice.